Liverpool Legend Questions United Boss’s Competence and Authority.

Jamie Carragher Ruben Amorim comments

Sky Sports pundit Jamie Carragher has delivered a brutal assessment of Ruben Amorim‘s tenure at Manchester United, directly responding to the head coach’s explosive post-match press conference after the 1-1 draw at Leeds United.

Carragher stated: “He’s not in a position to question those who appointed him. He’s not good enough to be Manchester United manager and, right now, he’s barely competent to manage in the Premier League.”

The former Liverpool defender’s remarks came amid Amorim’s frustration with the club’s hierarchy, where he insisted he was hired as a “manager” not just a “coach” and hinted at internal tensions over transfers and tactics. Carragher dismissed Amorim’s grievances, suggesting the issues stem from either lack of January backing or tactical disputes.

United’s form under Amorim has been inconsistent, with just one win in their last five Premier League games, leaving them fifth and outside the top four. The draw at Elland Road extended their unbeaten run against Leeds but highlighted ongoing struggles.

Carragher’s outspoken critique has sparked debate, with some viewing it as harsh given Amorim’s short time in charge since November 2024, while others agree the results don’t justify public complaints.

Gary Neville, Carragher’s co-pundit, interpreted Amorim’s words as a sign of unhappiness with the board.

As pressure mounts at Old Trafford, this latest controversy adds fuel to discussions about Amorim’s future.